How to achieve stability in PH

There's no denying he played a key role in Harapan's victory in GE14

There are some analysts who claim that Dr M didn't play as big a role in GE14 as some people think he did. I totally disagree. It was Dr M who proved to be the tipping point. So it is true when he says Najib would still be in power if not for Bersatu joining Pakatan Harapan.

But what is also true is that Najib would still be in power if PKR were not part of PH. It is also true that Najib would still in power if DAP were not part of PH. Repeat that sentence with regard to Amanah and Warisan.

The reality is that the various component parties in PH all need each other to form the majority in parliament.

Is this a good thing? In some respects yes because there is some form of mutual assured destruction if any one party decides not to play nice with the others. This mutual assure destruction forces everyone to behave reasonably in order to preserve the coalition government.

But it doesn't make for a very stable government. Any single party could bring down the government should it decide to leave. Which means every single party is actually a kingmaker. A party full of kingmakers doesn't make for stability in the long run.

So what needs to happen for there to be more stability in PH? One scenario calls for PKR, DAP and Amanah to among themselves get at least 112 seats in Parliament. These parties could still continue to work with Bersatu and Warisan but crucially, they don't need them. If the likes of Bersatu and Warisan start to exhibit UMNO-like behaviour, for example, they could be booted out and the coalition government would still hold.

This is stability. And it is achievable in GE15. At last count this trio has 103 MPs among them. They just need another nine more than they've reached the magic 112 number. Very doable and desirable too as it would keep Bersatu in check and ensure it doesn't morph into UMNO 2.0.

A team of rivals

Trouble brewing?

There could be a lot of turbulence in PKR in the coming months and years. It is in that unique situation where the president's deputy is also his rival.

That was the case with Dr M and Anwar in the 1990s remember? And look how that ended up.

It's very clear Azmin feels by now he has outgrown his role as Anwar's trusty lieutenant. Rafizi is content to play that role but not Azmin.

Will he challenge Anwar someday? Or might he actually quit PKR for Bersatu as some rumors and news reports suggest?

Who knows. Anything is possible in politics. Who would have thought it was possible for Anwar and Kit Siang to team up with Mahathir to oust Najib.

I consider myself a pretty savvy political observer -- and my comments published in newspaper columns and books over the years have proven to be quite accurate -- but just a few years ago if you had asked me if it was possible that Dr M would actually join the opposition and work with Anwar to try to defeat Najib, I would have said "Never in a million years".

So, anything is possible although it would be hard to imagine Azmin actually quitting PKR and joining Bersatu. That is really quite a stretch. What is more likely is perhaps some formal leadership challenge within PKR at some point. Perhaps when it comes closer for Anwar to take over as PM.

Does Dr M encourage this? Well, he did give Azmin a very powerful economic role despite the fact that he already had a capable finance minister. Why did he do that if not to bolster Azmin's credibility and gravitas? And why would he want to do that given that Azmin is not from his party? Hmmm... imponderables!

One thing you can be sure of though. Azmin may be savvy but Anwar is no novice in politics. If the rest of us can see what's happening, surely he sees it much better than we do and I'm sure he has plans and maneuvers in place in the eventuality of a challenge from Azmin.

It will be interesting times for PKR next year. Expect a lot of fireworks.

Let Nurul Izzah be

Mujahid's open letter to Nurul Izzah asking her to reconsider her decision to quit all her posts is downright embarrassing. Why try to convince her to change her mind in such a public manner?

If you are close to her and her family, why not speak to her privately and try to convince her directly? Why do this through an open letter?

On that note, lots of people were also wondering why Nurul Izzah and Rafizi decided to make so public their lunch with KJ? Instagram and all?

What point are they trying to make? Who knows.

And why did Nurul Izzah quit in the first place? Lots of speculations but she didn't say why and has made it clear she doesn't intend to.

That being the case, let her be.

What Mahathir says...

Mahathir made some big statements at the Bersatu AGM. Here are three key issues he touched on:

Call me racist but Malays are in decline and it’s our fault - Dr M
Dr M once again talks about how Malays need to change their values and how they have to get rid of their crutches. This is nothing new. He's been saying this for years. The problem is that at the very same time he's calling for Malays to rely more on themselves, he insists that affirmative action based on race must go on. Why must it be based on race? If affirmative action is based on need, everybody who needs help get help. What's wrong with that?

Dr M: No Bersatu positions for Umno defectors until after GE15
I think most Pakatan Harapan supporters would prefer for Bersatu to not take in any UMNO MPs at all. But if Bersatu is intent on opening its doors to some UMNO frogs, at the very least there needs to be some safeguards like this in place. Hopefully, they don't change their minds and make exceptions to this rule. If they do, it's a real slippery slope.

PM: Umno leaders can only dream about forming unity gov't
I recall reading with incredulity some UMNO leaders suggesting the idea of a unity government with PH. Why in the world would PH want to have any sort of unity government with the party they vanquished? Its not like PH is short of MPs to form the government. They have already formed the government! Why would they even consider bringing UMNO (not UMNO frogs, mind you but UMNO itself) into a unity government? The answer is they won't because it's such a ludicrous idea. If UMNO members didn't realize that then, they should realize that now. As Dr M says: Only in their dreams can they hope for this to happen.

What's Mahathir up to?

What is this wily master politician up to?

It's hard to tell what Dr M is up to these days. The simplistic view is that he is trying to bolster Bersatu's numbers by taking in former UMNO members.

Bersatu currently has 16 MPs while DAP has 42 and PKR 50. If as many as say 40 UMNO members were to join Bersatu, suddenly it would be the biggest component party in Pakatan Harapan.

Then, it would have the moral authority to call the shots in Pakatan, presumably. Right now, the only reason Bersatu has a disproportionate say in Pakatan matters is Dr M's gravitas and his critical role in helping Pakatan win GE14.

Pakatan components had agreed that he would be at the helm for around two years before handing it over to Anwar so it is only natural they will defer to him a bit. Pakatan could also use a steady, experienced hand to guide them through this tumultuous and unprecedented transition period. Plus, people want him around because they feel he -- more so than Anwar -- will see through the prosecution of all the corrupt politicians from the previous government.

All these factors have led to everyone giving Mahathir a lot of leeway. But his seeming willingness -- keeness even -- of taking in UMNO refugees has made a lot of people uneasy.

Having observed Mahathir since the mid-90s, I agree with the view that he is the master tactician when it comes to politics. As such I don't think he's simply trying to bolster Bersatu's members. He knows full well there are a lot of bad apples in UMNO. There may be some good ones like Mustapa Mohamed but those are few and far in between. Most of them supported Najib even when the 1MDB scandal broke wide open. Most of them poured scorn on Pakatan component parties when they thought that BN was undefeatable. And now they want to join Pakatan? Talk about opportunism.

I can't believe that Dr M doesn't see all this. So, what is he up to?

Despite him saying he wants a strong opposition, what's clear is Dr M wants to destroy UMNO. Perhaps by giving the impression that Bersatu is keen to take on ex-UMNO guys, this will encourage more to abandon the mother ship. But in the end, he will take on only a few. Then he would really have the last laugh.

Perhaps it's a bit cruel to give UMNO refugees some glimmer of hope of getting back into the government only to deny them that in the end. But I don't think Dr M is above having a bit of cruel fun at the expense of UMNO guys.

The other question on everybody's mind is whether he will stick to his promise of handing over the reigns to Anwar after about two years in office. On occasions he states clearly that he will stick to his promise. On other occasions he will equivocate, saying things like he will stay on as long as people want him and that Anwar can become the PM if people want him.

Saying things like that only make people wonder how committed he is to passing the baton to Anwar. But it's really hard to see how he can do otherwise. Even if Bersatu were to have say 56 members (the current 16 + the 40 supposed UMNO MPs who could cross over), PKR + DAP + Amanah = 50 + 42 + 11 = 103. That bloc has the majority and that block wants Anwar as PM.

Let's imagine a worst case scenario where things come to a head and Bersatu actually leaves Pakatan. And let's say for the sake of discussion that Warisan also no longer aligns with Pakatan out of solidarity with Bersatu. That would result in Pakatan having less than the 112 seats it needs to form the government (short by 9 seats). But one could easily imagine Anwar and gang getting nine crossovers from somewhere (most likely Sabah and perhaps a few from Sarawak).

In contrast what could Bersatu do? Having absorbed most of UMNO's lawmakers to bolster its numbers to 56, who else could he get to join him? MCA? MIC. Okay, another two or three seats. Who else? Some from Sabah and Sarawak, perhaps. Still won't get him up to 112 seats.

So, there is no way Bersatu can have the upper hand. In collaborating with Pakatan Rakyat to form Pakatan Harapan, Dr M had made a deal that allowed him to oust Najib but it does not allow him to lord over Pakatan the way he did BN. He simply does not have the numbers, with or without UMNO refugees.

The best that Dr M can hope for, given his age and the circumstances that he's in, is for UMNO to be destroyed, for corrupted politicians to be prosecuted and for his legacy to be enhanced by his amazing second act in Malaysian politics. His role in helping to topple Najib should not be underestimated. He played a crucial role there and history will remember him for that.

If he doesn't ruffle too many feathers in Pakatan he might even get his third national car although it would have to be largely a private sector initiative. He might also get some assurance that Bersatu MPs will get a decent number of Cabinet positions in future administrations. That's if he plays nice with the rest of Pakatan. But if he tries to have everything his way, he will for the first time fail badly and destroy any hope of legacy rehabilitation. I'm pretty sure Dr M knows that.